If we stop and pause for a moment to consider the above list, it is truly hard to conceive how they could possibly have made all these decisions, and carried them out, whilst all sitting down together for dinner in a public place at about 8.30pm until 10pm as if nothing had happened. In the same interview, she was asked a 49th question: Are you aware that in not answering these questions you are jeopardising the investigation into your daughters disappearance? Kate McCann answered: Yes, if thats what the investigation thinks. Then (assuming that they then decided that they are not going to inform the authorities of Madeleines death) there are more decisions to be made about what to do with Madeleines body: Or phone a trusted friend first and ask for advice? How very true, over nine years later, has that prophecy come true. Not only was Dr Payne not independent, being a very close friend of the McCanns, but there were 20 or more significant contradictions between the accounts of Dr Payne and Kate McCann about what took place at that meeting, how long it lasted etc. If that analysis is correct, this shows evidence of cunning planning and deception, amounting to perverting the course of justice. They has eaten in the Millennium Restaurant on the Saturday evening. Her mother came to fetch her at 12.25 for lunch and took her back at 2 o'clock. (iii) Or phone a trusted friend first and ask for advice? The unconvincing and vague evidence given by creche nanny Catriona Baker about what Madeleine was actually doing in the crche all week. It was not public knowledge, until earlier this year, that Sir Clement Freud - who twice invited the McCanns to his Praia da Luz home for eats and drinks in the weeks that followed Madeleines disappearance - had been a serial paedophile for decades. Chloe Corner, daughter of Jon Corner; Madeleines godfather, had been a Facebook friend of Catriona Baker well before 2007. Kate and Gerry McCann said it reflected progress in the . Gerry McCann gleefully quoted this case to try and prove his claim that cadaver dogs were unreliable. These are the relevant extracts from Goncalo Amarals book (AnnaEsses translation): On the fateful day of May 3rd, the attendance register at the play centre indicates that Madeleine arrived at 9.10, accompanied by her father. This issue was very fully addressed in Richard D. Halls third film about Madeleine McCann: When Madeleine Died? Without necessarily agreeing with every specific point he makes in that documentary, we adopt his main conclusions, so far as they go. She had a pink hair bead on her. Link However, a subsequent review of the samples determined that they had been contaminated by government Forensic Science Service staff. (as indeed they did so claim). Instead, they used the Head of Risks at PR company Bell Pottinger, Alex Woolfall, and their cousin, Michael Wright, to edit, crop and delete photographs from the McCanns memory cards before they were given to the police, on 9 May. These and a number of other considerations about Robert Murat lead us to think that he was summoned to Portugal during Monday 30 April because something serious had happened to Madeleine the previous day, and that his help was needed to cover this up. That also seems unlikely. The 'Last Photo' shows Gerry McCann, Madeleine and her sister Amelie by the Ocean Club swimming pool. German police said earlier that the suspect, who lived near Praia da Luz, has been sentenced on numerous occasions to prison terms for sexual abuse of children in the past. Her accounts lack any real detail of what Madeleine actually did in the creche that week. Madeleine could not have died after 6pm on Thursday 3 May. Maybe they would have had other related questions. To give but one recent example, dozens of people, including police and celebrities, knew that Jimmy Saville was a serial paedophile. The McCanns refusing to give their holiday photos to the police. Coffs coast. Recommended Stories The . When the film was published, the McCanns claimed she had been playing with Mummys make-up box, but that story didnt stand up to scrutiny. There is no other photo of Madeleine which with certainty can be said to have been taken after then, which we regard as hugely significant. Catriona Baker also had a holiday at the McCanns home a few months after Madeleine was reported missing, suggesting a close relationship between them.. Clear evidence that the McCanns pattern of behaviour changed after Sunday in the following ways: Taking breakfast every day after Sunday in their own apartment and not with their friends in the restaurant. Doubtful or contradictory stories about what they did with Madeleine after Sunday, for example: Claiming to have gone on a trip to the beach with the children one day - despite the creche records saying the children were in their creches at the time and promoting stories about things that she had allegedly said or done, Contradictory stories about an alleged incident of the children crying at night-time: on Thursday: (a) it was the twins (b) it was Madeleine (c) it was Madeleine and Sean and (d) it was Amelie on the Wednesday not the Thursday. In our view the involvement of Robert Murat in this case is another significant pointer to Madeleine having died on the Sunday. Now lets examine why we say she died on the Sunday. What possible good excuse could there be for lying so many times about the fate of a missing child? On at least one occasion, Rebelo suggested that he had firm evidence that the McCanns and their friends had. We suggest, given what we know, that there are two main possibilities: A deliberate violent act against her (not necessarily by one of the McCanns) , or. This was confirmed by Kate McCanns own account of the events of that week, in her book, Madeleine, which did nothing to remove all the question marks about the many contradictions and inconsistencies about what really happened that week. In McCann and Healy v.Portugal ([2022] ECHR 725)(in French only), the Fourth Section of the European Court of Human Rights held, unanimously, that the applicants' Article 8 rights had not been violated by the publication of a book, a documentary programme, and a newspaper interview alleging that the applicants' daughter had died inside their holiday flat and that the applicants had hidden . We have said that Madeleine was seen alive on Sunday 29th April at lunch-time. British girl Madeleine McCann went missing at the age of three while on holiday with her family in Portugal in 2007. . Madeleine McCann was born in Leicester born to her parents Kate and Gerry McCann know all about her Parents Net worth, Nationality, Ethnicity and Occupation . From that moment on, no other person saw the little girl, apart from her parents and their friends. A raft of evidence, but especially comparative weather records for the week, point in that direction. (as indeed they did so claim). We suggest, given what we know, that there are two main possibilities: There are indications which point in either of these directions, but not enough information to say which. Excerpts from the book by Gonalo Amaral, who believes that Madeleine McCann died inside the apartment at Praia da Luz. But they all kept silent. A very strange photo of Madeleine was published two years after Madeleine was reported missing. In our view the involvement of Robert Murat in this case is another significant pointer to Madeleine having died on the Sunday. Madeleine vanished from their holiday apartment in Praia da Luz on May 3 in 2007, days before her fourth birthday. dogs had alerted to dirty nappies, not the odour of a corpse, Kate Madeleine McCann went missing in 2007 (PA) 2014 . Hairs of the same haplotype as Robert Murat and Jane Tanner found in Krokowskis apartment. Look at the analysis of these sightings by HideHo that we referred to above. If Madeleine McCann's pyjamas were not in fact abducted, then nor was Madeleine McCann." Gerry McCann calls for example to be made of 'vile' internet trolls Brenda Leyland was doorstepped on 2 October 2014 by Sky reporter Martin Brunt who accused her of 'attacking' the McCanns. Rightly, Dr Roberts queries what was the point of the McCanns taking these photographs? 6 from what has been established up to now, everything indicates that the McCann couple, in self-defence, did not want to deliver up Madeleines corpse immediately and voluntarily, and there is a strong possibility therefore that it was moved from the initial place where she died. We finally decide to question her (Kate McCann) as a witness, but not to pose questions on the events after 5.30pm, the time at which she returned to the apartment with her three children. Even had they all rapidly agreed to go along with an abduction hoax later that evening at 10pm, there would be all manner of questions and suggestions. In the very early weeks after Madeleine was reported missing, John Stalker, an experienced and respected detective chosen to work on the alleged Shoot to Kill policy in Northern Ireland, stated that in his opinion: My gut instinct is that some big secret is being covered up. It has happened many times before in many other similar cases. Less than a month later, on 28 June 2007, Dr Gerry McCann said: I have no doubt we will be able to sustain a high profile for Madeleines disappearance in the long-term. Getty Images. ANSWER: Look at the analysis of these sightings by HideHo that we referred to above. ANSWER: Again there are many instances in history where large groups of people who know about a serious crime work together to keep the crime a secret. Then, again assuming that they had all agreed to a plan of action, there would be loads more questions about (a) the apartment and (b) how to execute the hoax. So, if she had died, say shortly after 6pm, as suggested by both Goncalo Amaral and Tavares de Almeida, what would the McCanns have had to do first? 3. We do not think it was. We now wish to take this research a stage further, and below is a short paper expressing the views of the Madeleine McCann Research Group. (AP) One of the prosecutors investigating the prime suspect in the Madeleine McCann disappearance has claimed she . Madeleine would have been happily playing with her brother and sister, her friends in the Lobsters club, and her Mum and Dad for six days. Her disappearance sparked an international search, with missing posters of the little girl's face papered across the world and celebrity appeals for information that could help track her down and bring her abductors to justice. In April, Portuguese police arrived in the United Kingdom to observe questioning conducted by Leicestershire Police of the McCanns' dinner guests on the night Madeleine vanished. But, according to the PJ theory, they must have been. 29, 11 Jun 2020; SINCE Madeleine McCann disappeared in 2007, many theories have been put forward to explain what happened to the youngster. On the very night when the McCanns and their friends should have been distraught, following Madeleines sudden disappearance, some of them were busy contacting the TV and print media and claiming, even in the very first hours after they had raised the alarm, that the Portuguese police were incompetent and not organising a proper search for her. Officials say new charges relate to offences allegedly committed in Portugal between 28 December 2000 and 11 June 2017 . The McCanns say the photo was taken at 2.29pm on Thursday 3 May. 3 min read. The McCanns issued sketches of a suspect on January 20th, based on a description of a "scary man" observed at the resort by a British holidaymaker. McCann had certified six deaths in the two weeks before going on Later, when re-interviewed by the Portuguese police on 10 and 11 July, after police had interrogated his mobile phone, and discovered that the account he had earlier given of his movements was false, he completely changed his story, claiming he had been too tired on 15 May to tell the truth. Is there any other reason why we dare not risk going to hospital and possibly facing a post-mortem? We agree with his explanation, which can be viewed here: http://onlyinamericablogging.blogspot.com/2016/03/a-nightwear-job-by-dr-martin-roberts.html, Specific indications that Madeleine died on Sunday 29 April. This booking appears to have been made on the Sunday night. This is consistent with her having been dead for some time before she was reported missing. KATE and Gerry McCann may be told within days how their daughter Madeleine died. After jogging on the beach and going to fetch the twins, she collected Maddie at 5.30pm. No-one else was reported to have ever died in that apartment. If Madeleine died after 6pm on 3 May, what would the McCanns have had to do? It was very early - Madeleine might very well have been found alive and well later that Friday - but on that very day, many media editors immediately despatched reporters to Praia da Luz. If so, they would need to demonstrate that the shutters were previously in good working order. (iv) Where can we get a car quickly so as to hide it? Mrs Fenns statement was trailed in advance in the British press in articles which showed every sign of being planted by the McCann Teams PR agent, Clarence Mitchell. Mrs Pamela Fenn, a widow who lived above the McCanns, heard Madeleine crying between 10.30pm and 11.45pm on Tuesday night. Quite apart from anything else, why did he delay for six days reporting a man taking photos of children on a beach and who later that day tried to kidnap his daughter? It is a fact that from about 8am on Friday 4 May, the news of Madeleines reported disappearance rapidly became the top story in both Portugal and Britain for weeks - and has continued to make international headlines ever since. Some suggest that maybe the body wasnt hidden before 8.30pm, but lay there while they were eating, with someone - presumably Gerry McCann later carrying his dead daughter to a temporary or final resting place somewhere after that. It was a tragic accident in the apartment that night.'. She claimed in her statement that the crying she heard was that of a child more than two - but no-one can distinguish between the cry of a two-year-old (the McCanns twins) and three-year-old (Madeleine). She had a gold-coloured necklace put around her neck. But we believe we now have sufficient knowledge to be able to state with confidence what we say below. However, in our view it is very unlikely that her death could have been a simple accident, otherwise the McCanns would have taken her to the local hospital. he room forensically cleaned of any blood? . 3 May Madeleine disappears from a holiday apartment at the Ocean Club resort in the Algarve village of Praia da Luz, while her parents, Kate and Gerry McCann, dine with friends at a nearby tapas . Then there would be another very tricky question to answer: Just our very good friends David and Fiona? There is agreement from the McCanns, their friends, other holidaymakers and Ocean Club staff that they were all settled at their table at around 8.30pm to 8.45pm. But it later emerged that the Director and his deputy from a Bell Pottinger subsidiary company, Resonate, had flown out to help Mark Warner just days before, possibly on Monday 30 April. The problem with the Tennis Balls Photo. Have we got anything we can carry her body out in, without anybody thinking there might be a body in it? That conclusion is greatly enhanced by the McCanns first and subsequent reactions to these dramatic findings, which we have set out in detail elsewhere. Could they have discussed this desperate situation bilaterally? Police said they wanted to speak to a thus-far unidentified second person who spoke with the German suspect from a Portuguese phone number on May 3, 2007 at the time of McCann's disappearance. The absence of confirmed photos of Madeleine on the holiday from the Last Photo onwards. Point 5. A third (but we say unlikely) possibility is that she did suffer a genuine accident, but that the McCanns did not produce her to the local hospital because there may have been indications that Madeleine had previously suffered some form of harm or abuse. If she died after 6pm on Thursday 3 May, what would the McCanns and their friends have had to do in the four hours between 6pm and 10pm? If Madeleine died after 6pm on 3 May, what would the McCanns have had to do? The very next day, early in the morning, a man called Nuno Lourenco rang the Portuguese police and said that, six days previously, a man was taking photographs of children on a beach had tried to kidnap his child at a tiny village called Sagres. As a Netflix documentary sparks new interest in the case, we look at the v It follows from all that we have said above that, if Madeleine did indeed die on Sunday 29 April, those who knew she had died must have carefully planned an audacious hoax over a period of four days, so cunning and clever that most people still believe that she was abducted. Chapter 5: The days that followed. Kate and Gerry McCann, the parents of the missing 4-year-old British girl Madeleine McCann, hold up a picture of Madeleine during a press conference on June 6, 2007 in Berlin, Germany. views of the Madeleine McCann Research Group, The . Thats 24 times as much time to think, plan and carry out a hoax abduction. They refused to hand over their photographs without first selecting exactly what they wanted the police to see and what they didnt want them to see. He was contacted by one of Britains mainstream press in the early hours of the morning, before the media storm broke at about 8am on the Friday morning. McCann used to carry Madeleines favourite cuddly toy, Cuddle "Kate McCann and Gerald McCann are involved in the concealment of the cadaver of their daughter, Madeleine McCann" George Moras, Honorary Chief Commissioner of the National French Police "Today, the only person prosecuted in the case of the disappearance of little Madeleine McCann is the officer who conducted the investigation. At the Inquest the coroner said there was no evidence as to how he had come to take morphine, and no needle mark was found. Specific indications that Madeleine died on Sunday 29 April. It is a fact that from about 8am on Friday 4 May, the news of Madeleines reported disappearance rapidly became the top story in both Portugal and Britain for weeks - and has continued to make international headlines ever since. For example, on 3 June 2007, just one month after Madeleine went missing, Gerry McCann was planning a big event to mark Madeleines abduction, telling the press: We want a big event to raise awareness that she is still missingIt wouldnt be a one-year anniversary, it will be sooner than that. He wanted Elton John to front a major fund-raising concert. AA. But we suggest that instead of having four hours to plan an abduction hoax, they actually had four days. His conduct whilst a translator in those early days after Madeleine was reported missing was bizarre and suspicious. In such a scenario, the McCanns would probably contact their friends on their mobiles. Only one other photo of Madeleine was taken that week, the so-called Tennis Balls Photo. None of them stand up to serious scrutiny. Again there are many instances in history where large groups of people who know about a serious crime work together to keep the crime a secret. There would have been a severe emotional reaction and initial panic, and maybe a series of irrational responses, before they could properly gather their thoughts and begin to come to terms with the shock of losing their daughter and start planning how to cover it up. Quite why the British Embassy would promote Murat to do this job is uncertain, unless he had a significant prior connection with the Embassy, and was co-operating with them in some way. There are indications which point in either of these directions, but not enough information to say which. and claimed that she had been abducted by a paedophile gang. He also described the man as of medium height, with long black hair, wearing cloth clothes and classic shoes, who didnt look like a tourist. . We think there are good grounds for suspecting that the two photos may have been taken on the same day, and that Madeleines very sad appearance could be connected in some way to her having died later that same day. Finally, they would have to arrange the crime scene, that is, the childrens bedroom, to make it look like an abduction had occurred - moved the beds. In early 2009, Brian Kennedy, the Cheshire businessman who led the McCann Teams private investigations, helped to create a bogus private investigation company, ALPHAIG Ltd. We also need to bear in mind that on the basis of the PJ theory as it stands, this was a holiday to a place the McCanns had never been to before. But for the purposes of this paper, we shall assume that she was there at 6pm.. Later on, the evidence suggests that the McCanns and their friends dined at the Tapas restaurant. Chapter 3: Announcement of a disappearance: The fi. The reason given by the McCanns and their friends for making this booking is even stranger. We know for certain that three photographs were taken of Madeleine playing happily in the Ocean Club playground in Praia da Luz in the late afternoon or early evening of the first day of the McCanns holiday - Saturday 28 April (this disposes of the views of some people who have claimed that Madeleine was never on that holiday). We believe that there are a considerable number of people who know what really happened to Madeleine but will not speak of what they know. Catriona Baker also had a holiday at the McCanns home a few months after Madeleine was reported missing, suggesting a close relationship between them.. All of these, we say, are wholly consistent with something very serious having happened to Madeleine McCann on the Sunday. He had carefully fitted up Krokowski. Portugal's Attorney General agreed to reopen the investigation into Madeleine McCann's disappearance in October 2013, more than five years after it was archived, following a formal request . Chapter 7: Suspicious behaviour and contradictions. Evidence that the children of the McCanns and their friends were cared for in one room from Sunday night onwards, After Dr Amaral was removed as the investigation co-ordinator in October 2007, he was replaced by Paulo Rebelo. On the very night when the McCanns and their friends should have been distraught, following Madeleines sudden disappearance, some of them were busy contacting the TV and print media and claiming, even in the very first hours after they had raised the alarm, that the Portuguese police were incompetent and not organising a proper search for her. blood Updated. (vi) Can we get all this done before 8.30pm, when were supposed to meet our friends for dinner? But those who claim that Madeleine died after 6pm have to explain how the McCanns were able to pull off an audacious abduction within the four hours between 6pm and 10pm (when the alarm was raised) on Thursday 3 May. Later, Robert Murat claimed that Mrs Fenn had phoned him, not Mrs Glyn, about the alleged crying. It showed Madeleine in make-up. In such a scenario, how likely is it that all six friends would have agreed within, say, 5-10 minutes that they would all play their roles in a fake abduction? Here we rely mainly on the analyses by long-time Madeleine McCann researcher HideHo, who has examined all claimed sightings of Madeleine from Monday onwards, and found each one to be either vague, otherwise unsubstantiated or uncorroborated, or subject to contradictory evidence. In his analysis, Dr Roberts publishes disturbing evidence that Madeleines pyjamas may have been photographed on a blue hessian background, similar to that of the settee in the McCanns apartment, earlier during the day (3 May) when the alarm about Madeleine was raised. Chapter 2: Madeleine Beth McCann's holiday. If that analysis is correct, this shows evidence of cunning planning and deception, amounting to perverting the course of justice. (v) Would we be investigated by the police? IE 11 is not supported. We are sure that this high tea did not take place; the contradictions about it are too many and too serious. In the intervening years, a huge, costly police operation has taken place across much of Europe . This suggests that Lourenco was part of a group of people who planned to deliberately sabotage the Portuguese polices investigation and send them off in entirely the wrong direction. They claimed that they were leaving their children on their own and checking on them, but still wanted to be able to see their apartment from the restaurant. It is time for us now to be still more specific about why we think she died on the Sunday that week. Here we set out, briefly, some key objections to our theory - and provide our responses: Nobody could keep up the pretence that their daughter had been abducted - knowing that she was dead - for so long (nine years now). Madeleine McCann went missing, aged three, in 2007. The McCanns say the photo was taken at 2.29pm on Thursday 3 May. The German man, who was not publicly named, lived in the Algarve between 1995 and 2007 and burgled hotels and holiday apartments as well as dealing drugs, German police said. This issue was very fully addressed in Richard D. Halls third film about Madeleine McCann: When Madeleine Died? Without necessarily agreeing with every specific point he makes in that documentary, we adopt his main conclusions, so far as they go. In addition to all these considerations, for Martin Grimes cadaver dogs to have alerted to the scent of a corpse, no longer present, some three months after the McCanns had vacated their holiday apartment, Madeleines body must have been lying in the McCanns apartment for at least 90 minutes, probably two hours or longer.